23450's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[3:33am]

jesus man

you scared the living fuck right out of me! thats all i really have to say...you know it looks good, you know you did good, you dont need me to tell you that. But man, lol, great job. Im so on edge right now because of that.

[Somebody's Watching Me]

Graphics good, song bad

Very good job. But im really not a big fan of the song. To old, retro, and im really not into "classical" music, just seemed corny and cliched.

but, im giving you a good score because i friggin loved the graphics. While not super super amazing, i can see you tryed hard to make it look good, and it worked very well, i loved it. well done.

[Madness Antipathy]

worst yet

The one thing i loved about you and this series was that it seemed as if you tryed very hard to make improvements on it with every installment. Something different, new, at least for the series itself. And it always, always got better with each passing episode. Except in this case. One major flaw i seemed to notice was the music. It did not seen nearly as well composed at Apothioses. The animation itself did not seem to change much, no improvement there, unlike in most where there was some sort of improvement.

And most of all, i did not feel it was as climactic as alot of your earlier submissions. I was just not exited for it near the and as i was others. In the next installment, i suggest doing more to make it different. Still madness, but something that brings it apart from the other installments. Good luck.

[Joker and the Thief]

great job man

You did a very good job with this thing. The song fit very well with the animation and basic concept of it all. the 3D houses did not distract at all, as some 3D does in these 2D movies. Actually made everything look better. I loved the character, good job with it.

Its all better then the pervious work ive seen from yah, so you accomplished everything you need to i think. keep trucking man. good luck.

[HOCKLES]

terrible

a very very bad idea man. very easily done and simple to do, but the thing that brings it way way done, is how bad of an idea it is. how did you think this would ever be interesting or entertaining in any kind of way? If you have fun watching and/or playing your movie/game, then other people will as well. do you have fun playing this? i would really doubt it. so yah, think up a more entertaining idea next time. good luck with your future project.

[Almost Home]

...

aside from arfenhouse, thats got to be the most random shit i have ever seen. lol. well done.

ConAir responds:

Noted.

[Where I belong]

Great animation man

Jesus man. How the fuck does this not have a higher score? it really does deserve more. Animation wise that is.

The only thing i can see bringing this way way down is the story. It seems very dull and generic. You really have to work on writting a little bit more. Take a look at my submission provincial Practice. In comparison to this, the animation is complete shit. But with the storyline it had, it has a score just about up to this.

Backgrounds could also some work as well. While they look fine and do not really take away from it all, it would really help if they were more detailed and well drawn. people should be able to look at a background without the character and still think it looks good. In this case, when i concentrated on the character, the background did not bother me. But if i looked behind the character and really took a look at it all, they were fairly simple and...not bad, just not relitively good.

Overall, very fucking well done sir. I loved the character, drawn very well in all the scenes. So story and backgrounds and you have yourself a 4+ flash i believe.

Ginga-densetsu-killa responds:

Heh, thanks, The reason behind the storyline is that i wanted it to be a short animation not one one drags on.

["Edmonton"]

Deserves to pass

Deafinantly does not deserve to be blammed. Deacently done. Fucking love Blow Me Away. Not a huge fan of thier latest CD....oh wells.

BTW: Grande Prairie tEh Best-z0r!!!

[TANKMEN]

Great Movie Man

You did a very good job with this. Voice acting was great, animation was smooth, humour was slikghtly dry, but i loved it none the less. One thing that suprised me about you, is that your actually responding to reviews. Submissions in the top 50 dont get very many responses, due to the large amount of reviews. I respect you for taking the time to read them. And yah, great job. Look forward to others you have to release.

JohnnyUtah responds:

thanks, appreciate it dude

[Carrot Juice!]

gwgwgwe

jesus christ man. how the fuck did you guys come up with this engine. stupid flash going 3D. im happy yet afraid our last hope at 2D animation is lost.